A soft veil of smoke slowly settles over the darkness. Cinnamon and black pepper sharpens the silhouette, dry wisps of elemi and incense unfold, rosemary anchors. Leather, woods and earthy tones seep in with silent depth. By the end, a restrained warmth lingers like an afterglow. All Black reveals without showing.
Best Treacle by Pineward Perfumes Alternatives & Similar Perfumes
Treacle by Pineward Perfumes is an aromatic spicy fragrance centred on rich tobacco softened by sweet molasses, honey, and raisin, complemented by the smoky depth of lapsang souchong tea. The blend balances warmth and sweetness with a subtle smoky undertone, creating a gourmand yet robust scent. Those drawn to Treacle should focus on fragrances that combine tobacco with sweet or smoky elements for a similarly layered effect.
New to Bloom? Get 10% off your first order with code NICHE10
1
Or du Sérail by Naomi Goodsir £141.67
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £5.83
- Key notes:
- honey
- mango
- tobacco
- Aromagroups:
- leather
- spicy
- woody
New 2019 packaging: crimped spray (as opposed to the previous design of screw-on self assembly spray).
Perfumer: Bertrand Duchaufour.
Or du Sérail exudes almost gooey intoxicating sweetness of a cigar soaked in rum with hints of candied fruit and honey at the edges.
You can relate to this perfume if you ever discovered that secret cupboard your grandma kept spice, vanilla, honey, cognac, candied oranges and chocolate among other fragrant treasures reserved for festive cake making. When you finally locate it, you just linger at the open door and marvel at the rich, sweet aromas, before checking if there’s anything worth secretly tasting.
Tobacco, very much present in the formula probably stands for the antic cabinet itself.
The Sniff on Au de Serail:
"There is a sugared, decadent and festive tone about the start of the scent without a doubt. The feeling that it evokes is of a Victorian Christmas celebration; opening a giant box of Christmas sweets and staring at the amassed rows of candied fruit lying in their little compartments, the jewelled colours glinting in the light of the log fire."
2
Sexual Healing by Art Meets Art £91.67
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £5.00
- Key notes:
- ginger
- honey
- tobacco
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- spicy
Perfumer: Christophe Raynaud accepted the challenge of translating into a perfume the soft and sensual voice of Marvin Gaye singing Sexual Healing…
3
Živeli by Boka £179.17
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £7.50
- Key notes:
- brandy
- honey
- leather
- mandarin
- plum
- saffron
- tobacco
- tonka beans
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- fruity
- woody
“Živeli” (ZHEE-vuh-lee) is a common Serbian toast used to wish good health and a long life. In this extrait, a juicy burst of plum brandy melts into a leathered tobacco, encapsulating a celebratory night out with friends. Giddy joy is further fluffed by cherry and raspberry notes, while the leather aspect is warmed by honey, saffron and labdanum.
This composition is 24% parfum concentration, with 70% natural ingredients. Capped in Mexican Riviera Gray marble in a delicately etched glass bottle.
4
004 Gin Cologne by Bon Parfumeur £87.50
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £3.33
- Key notes:
- juniper
- mandarin
- tobacco
- tonka beans
- Aromagroups:
- citrusy
- green
Perfumer: Karine Dubreuil – Sereni
The fourth fragrance in the citrusy section of Bon Parfumeur’s library of perfume themes. This time it’s mandarin gin, juicy and green with a bit of spicy sweet tobacco in the background.
5
20359 by 32.JULI £129.17
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £7.50
- Key notes:
- cherry
- heliotrope
- latex
- tobacco
- tonka beans
- Aromagroups:
- fruity
- woody
Glowing red in the dusk, this latex cherry is spiced with clove, dusted with heliotrope, rolled in vanilla, smoked in tobacco. It’s cushy and cozy, but just a little wicked. 20359 is the postcode of St Pauli, the Hamburg district where 32.JULI was founded. For centuries, sailors arriving through Hamburg's harbour, artists, musicians and night owls have shaped the neighbourhood's unmistakable character. Known for its independent spirit, iconic nightlife and historic red light district, Sankt Pauli is a place where stories begin. The fragrance captures the anticipation of an evening just unfolding, lifting the cocktail cherry from the first drink of the night.
6
902 Hazy Spice by Bon Parfumeur £95.83
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £3.33
- Key notes:
- cognac
- labdanum
- tobacco
- Aromagroups:
- leather
- woody
A moreish blend of dark, syrupy prunes soaked in cognac and cinnamon. The boozy richness is offset with tobacco. Interesting and smart.
Perfumer for 902: Karine Dubreuil-Sereni.
7
Agrani by Byermia £100.00
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £6.67
- Key notes:
- castoreum
- cocoa
- leather
- oud
- tobacco
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- leather
- vintage/old school
- woody
The word “agrani” in Sanskrit means a leader, a trailblazer, and this perfume embodies the life stages of a leader. The opening burst of cherry, almond and saffron symbolises the mesmerising oratory skills that rally the masses. The heart reveals the power of pipe tobacco and leather, expressing a leader’s fearless revolutionary spirit. Enveloping musk and Burmese oud summons the hope they bring during challenging times. The cacao and castoreum base evokes the lasting impact they have on the world, leaving an indelible impression. And finally, the warmth of amber echoes the rays of hope a leader ignites in future generations.
8
All Black by Insenf £104.17
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £5.83
- Key notes:
- black pepper
- castoreum
- gaiac / guaiac wood
- incense
- rosemary
- tobacco
- Aromagroups:
- aromatic
- leather
9
Anti-Blues by Pierre Guillaume Black Collection £162.50
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £6.67
- Key notes:
- cocoa
- dark chocolate
- incense
- saffron
- tobacco
- vanilla
- vetiver
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- leather
- unconventional
- woody
A socially acceptable way to smell like you spend your downtime writhing naked in milky melted chocolate, spiced with saffron, smoked by tobacco, caressed by vanilla. Cue eyes-rolling-back-in-their-head pleasure for anyone who smells you.
10
Atman Xaman (EdT) by Lorenzo Villoresi £125.00
Not sure yet? Try a 1 ml sample for £5.00
- Key notes:
- amber
- incense
- leather
- tobacco
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- woody
A deep, intense, mysterious fragrance that radiates unique atmospheres: magical, spiritual, real and imaginary.
An enveloping scent of Leather, Tobacco and precious woods with light undertones of flowers and wild herbs, on a gentle, sensual background of fragrant resins, of Vanilla and Patchouli, of Amber and Musk.
About Treacle by Pineward Perfumes
- How does Treacle differ from these fragrances?
- Treacle is characterised by its unique combination of tobacco, lapsang souchong tea, molasses, honey, and raisin, creating a sweet, smoky, and slightly fruity aromatic spicy scent. While the listed fragrances share tobacco and some sweet or smoky elements, none replicate the distinctive tea and molasses accord that defines Treacle.
- Which fragrances here are the sweetest compared to Treacle?
- Or du Sérail and Anti-Blues are among the sweetest, sharing honey and vanilla notes that complement tobacco. Agrani also has a sweet edge with cocoa and castoreum. These fragrances highlight the sweeter facets of tobacco that Treacle offers.
- Are there fresher alternatives to Treacle on this list?
- Yes, 004 Gin Cologne and Audacity both incorporate fresh, citrusy, or herbal notes alongside tobacco, providing a lighter, more invigorating interpretation compared to Treacle’s warm and sweet profile.